Highgarden Real Estate
REALTOR ®
(317) 565-7160
Email Taylor
mobile navigation links

Below you can view all the homes for sale in the Butler Tarkington subdivision located in Indianapolis Indiana. Listings in Butler Tarkington are updated daily from data we receive from the Indianapolis multiple listing service.

To learn more about any of these homes or to receive custom notifications when a new property is listed for sale in Butler Tarkington, give us a call at 317-565-7160.

54 Results

Butler Tarkington Indianapolis Indiana Homes For Sale

Butler Tarkington For Sale $589,900

View 3906 Graceland Ave Indianapolis IN
View Details 1 Photo
On Market For 2 Days

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    2860

  • Year Built

    2024

  • $/SqFt

    $206

Schedule a consultation today to learn more about this exceptional new construction project. MLS#21993279. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $560,000

View 4123 N Illinois St Indianapolis IN
View Details 44 Photos
View 4123 N Illinois St Indianapolis IN
View 4123 N Illinois St Indianapolis IN
View 4123 N Illinois St Indianapolis IN
On Market For 2 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    3008

  • Year Built

    1926

  • $/SqFt

    $186

Don't miss out on this stunning property in Butler-Tarkington. MLS#21999162. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $449,900

View 5270 Boulevard Pl Indianapolis IN
View Details 43 Photos
View 5270 Boulevard Pl Indianapolis IN
View 5270 Boulevard Pl Indianapolis IN
View 5270 Boulevard Pl Indianapolis IN
On Market Today

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    3210

  • Year Built

    1931

  • $/SqFt

    $140

Beautiful Professionally Landscaped Mature Yard. One Car Garage Too! MLS#21999544. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $250,000

View 3827 Graceland Ave Indianapolis IN
View Details 18 Photos
View 3827 Graceland Ave Indianapolis IN
View 3827 Graceland Ave Indianapolis IN
View 3827 Graceland Ave Indianapolis IN
On Market For 2 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2195

  • Year Built

    1910

  • $/SqFt

    $114

New appliances will be installed prior to move in. MLS#21999734. Matlock Realty Group.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $250,000

View Details 30 Photos
On Market For 8 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1104

  • Year Built

    1970

  • $/SqFt

    $226

Within walking distance to so many amenities: Tarkington Park, Butler University, Mid-Town, Broad Ripple, the Indianapolis Children's Museum, Newfields and easy access to downtown Indianapolis. Schedule a showing today! MLS#21991702. CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

Butler Tarkington Pended $425,000

View Details 49 Photos
On Market For 14 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    3198

  • Year Built

    1922

  • $/SqFt

    $133

Other updates: Kinetico water softner(2020) Garage Dining Room opener(2020) Radon (2019) MLS#21996360. Berkshire Hathaway Home.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $205,000

View Details 26 Photos
On Market For 16 Days

  • Bedrooms

    2

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    1820

  • Year Built

    1941

  • $/SqFt

    $113

Don't miss out on this exceptional opportunity! MLS#21997823. Blue Sky Realty Group.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $850,000

View Details 43 Photos
On Market For 16 Days

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    4067

  • Year Built

    1930

  • $/SqFt

    $209

You'll have to see them for yourself! MLS#21996612. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $799,900

View Details 51 Photos
*POTENTIAL GREAT VALUE
On Market For 16 Days

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    4826

  • Year Built

    1928

  • $/SqFt

    $166

Come take a look before it's too late! MLS#21997492. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington Pended $550,000

View Details 29 Photos
On Market For 16 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    3687

  • Year Built

    1937

  • $/SqFt

    $149

Butler Tarkington offers walkability, a host of local businesses and a community feel, not to mention the fun of Butler University. MLS#21996881. @properties.

Butler Tarkington Pended $439,000

View Details 39 Photos
On Market For 15 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    2914

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $151

Don't miss this amazing opportunity! All appliances stay. MLS#21997257. Maywright Property Co..

Butler Tarkington Pended $425,000

View Details 29 Photos
On Market For 22 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2460

  • Year Built

    1936

  • $/SqFt

    $173

So much to love in this home and neighborhood. Welcome Home! MLS#21994014. Good Living Indy, LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $525,000

View Details 40 Photos
On Market For 22 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2377

  • Year Built

    1930

  • $/SqFt

    $221

Rebuilt (concrete) driveway and expanded garage-added 4 ft of depth, with new garage slab, gutters, door, and opener mechanism and new steps to side door of house, 2019. MLS#21995969. Compass Indiana, LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $230,000

View Details 25 Photos
On Market For 23 Days

  • Bedrooms

    2

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1920

  • Year Built

    1925

  • $/SqFt

    $120

Roof and mechanicals are 6 years old or less. Brand new Septic clean out! MLS#21996263. RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $150,000

Reduced By $10,000
View Details 3 Photos
On Market For 26 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2146

  • Year Built

    1925

  • $/SqFt

    $70

The home sits on almost a 1/4 acre lot with tons of mature trees and privacy. MLS#21995631. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $300,000

Reduced By $9,000
View Details 15 Photos
On Market For 29 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2288

  • Year Built

    1922

  • $/SqFt

    $131

New HVAC, New Roof, New Paint, New flooring, Updated electrical and plumbing. MLS#21994496. Real Broker, LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $330,000

View Details 61 Photos
On Market For 31 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2121

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $156

Don't miss the opportunity to make this charming property your own! MLS#21994601. Indy Homes Realty Group.

Butler Tarkington Pended $292,000

Reduced By $5,000
View Details 37 Photos
On Market For 34 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1491

  • Year Built

    1930

  • $/SqFt

    $196

Walking distance to Butler's campus, Andrew Ramsey Park, Chillywater Taproom, Hoagies & Hops, and many more fun places. Come see it today!! ! MLS#21993796. United Real Estate Indpls.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $215,000

Reduced By $10,000
View Details 34 Photos
On Market For 37 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2160

  • Year Built

    1943

  • $/SqFt

    $100

Unfinished basement provides plenty of extra storage. HVAC is 2 years old MLS#21991335. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $799,900

View Details 45 Photos
On Market For 14 Days

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    5

  • Sq. Ft.

    4770

  • Year Built

    1935

  • $/SqFt

    $168

This is as turn-key as you'll find in Midtown. MLS#21991897. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $549,900

View Details 56 Photos
On Market For 45 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2652

  • Year Built

    1926

  • $/SqFt

    $207

Don't miss the chance to make this amazing property your own! MLS#21992439. eXp Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $265,000

Reduced By $45,000
View Details 29 Photos
On Market For 50 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2160

  • Year Built

    1943

  • $/SqFt

    $123

Don't miss out on this fantastic opportunity to live in a vibrant community with convenient access to all corners of the city. MLS#21991160. CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $330,000

View Details 14 Photos
On Market For 51 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1890

  • Year Built

    1943

  • $/SqFt

    $175

Garage is currently being used as storage. MLS#21991379. The Real Estate Alternative.

Butler Tarkington Pended $315,000

Reduced By $10,000
View Details 35 Photos
*POTENTIAL GREAT VALUE
On Market For 49 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2891

  • Year Built

    1915

  • $/SqFt

    $109

Roof 2019, upper level exterior siding 2021, security system 2019, screen door 2020. MLS#21990584. Berkshire Hathaway Home.

Butler Tarkington Pended $2,500,000

View Details 95 Photos
On Market For 51 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    5884

  • Year Built

    1930

  • $/SqFt

    $425

This prime location just blocks from shops, cafes, and dining is a rare opportunity. MLS#21986119. Encore Sotheby's International.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $525,000

Reduced By $44,999
View Details 57 Photos
On Market For 56 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    3336

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $157

Ten minutes or less to Lucas Oil, Bankers Life, IUPUI, Butler, Marion, IMA, RH Estate, Broad Ripple, new IU hospital campus. MLS#21990353. Compass Indiana, LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $390,000

Reduced By $9,990
View Details 25 Photos
On Market For 57 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2202

  • Year Built

    1941

  • $/SqFt

    $177

With its prime location, updated features, and ample space for your family's needs, this property is the perfect fit! MLS#21989398. Indy Home Shop LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $295,000

Reduced By $30,000
View Details 61 Photos
On Market For 64 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2499

  • Year Built

    1902

  • $/SqFt

    $118

Electric bills average $15 a month due to solar panels used for electric efficiency. MLS#21989136. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington Pended $119,900

Reduced By $15,100
View Details 25 Photos
*POTENTIAL GREAT VALUE
On Market For 49 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2664

  • Year Built

    1921

  • $/SqFt

    $45

Seller is selling as-is but is not aware of any issues. MLS#21988274. No Limit Real Estate, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $395,000

View Details 28 Photos
On Market For 67 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2945

  • Year Built

    1918

  • $/SqFt

    $134

Located conveniently for quick access to downtown Indianapolis and Broad Ripple, you'll have easy reach to a plethora of dining and shopping options. MLS#21988229. CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $469,000

Reduced By $6,000
View Details 34 Photos
On Market For 71 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2685

  • Year Built

    1937

  • $/SqFt

    $175

Free up more of your free time with the easy-care lawn. MLS#21985847. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington Pended $449,900

View Details 45 Photos
On Market For 70 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2493

  • Year Built

    1929

  • $/SqFt

    $180

- Updates since listing: New balcony, updated kitchen, new paint, new hardware, new fixtures, new garage door opener, and updated landscaping. MLS#21984605. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $274,900

Reduced By $24,100
View Details 57 Photos
On Market For 73 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2052

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $134

Schedule your showing today and make this stunning residence yours! MLS#21986068. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $369,900

Reduced By $30,000
View Details 47 Photos
On Market For 76 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2413

  • Year Built

    1910

  • $/SqFt

    $153

Don't miss out on this great home! MLS#21986722. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $399,000

Reduced By $26,000
View Details 25 Photos
On Market For 80 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2472

  • Year Built

    1923

  • $/SqFt

    $161

Enjoy the convenience of a short commute to campus and the vibrant academic atmosphere of the Butler-Tarkington neighborhood. MLS#21986167. Mosley Real Estate Agency, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $274,900

Reduced By $25,000
View Details 48 Photos
On Market For 59 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2160

  • Year Built

    1943

  • $/SqFt

    $127

The Seller Is Willing To Install 4th Bedroom Off Of The Kitchen Or In The Basement MLS#21984966. RE/MAX Advanced Realty.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $189,900

Reduced By $8,600
View Details 28 Photos
On Market For 86 Days

  • Bedrooms

    1

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    1040

  • Year Built

    1968

  • $/SqFt

    $183

A prime location just minutes to downtown and everything Indianapolis has to offer. MLS#21984415. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington Pended $225,000

View Details 34 Photos
*POTENTIAL GREAT VALUE
On Market For 86 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2000

  • Year Built

    1968

  • $/SqFt

    $113

Bonus room over parking garage that no other unit has. Great additional space. MLS#21983681. CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $239,900

Reduced By $50,000
View Details 29 Photos
On Market For 99 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1811

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $132

This is the perfect starter home. Come see it today!! ! MLS#21982504. United Real Estate Indpls.

Butler Tarkington Pended $315,000

Reduced By $25,000
View Details 29 Photos
On Market For 95 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1832

  • Year Built

    1924

  • $/SqFt

    $172

A TWO-car garage, back deck and fenced-in yard complete the package. MLS#21973685. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $275,000

Reduced By $74,900
View Details 28 Photos
On Market For 107 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1983

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $139

With its blend of timeless charm and modern amenities, this home is sure to captivate from the moment you step inside. MLS#21979371. Four Points Realty LLC.

Butler Tarkington Pended $175,000

Reduced By $4,900
View Details 26 Photos
On Market For 120 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    1128

  • Year Built

    1920

  • $/SqFt

    $155

Come see what this house has to offer! MLS#21978577. Roofstock Realty, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $450,000

Reduced By $25,000
View Details 44 Photos
On Market For 117 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    2395

  • Year Built

    1933

  • $/SqFt

    $188

All this situated on a quiet, 2 block street in Butler Tarkington is truly a dream! MLS#21975161. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $390,000

Reduced By $10,000
View Details 13 Photos
On Market For 83 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2621

  • Year Built

    1949

  • $/SqFt

    $149

Property photos have been enhanced with virtual staging. MLS#21976517. Highgarden Real Estate.

Butler Tarkington Pended $205,000

Reduced By $32,000
View Details 21 Photos
On Market For 126 Days

  • Bedrooms

    2

  • Full Bath(s)

    1

  • Sq. Ft.

    1313

  • Year Built

    1912

  • $/SqFt

    $156

This home is sure to impress from the moment you step inside. MLS#21966791. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $689,900

Reduced By $105,100
View Details 46 Photos
On Market For 163 Days

  • Bedrooms

    5

  • Full Bath(s)

    4

  • Sq. Ft.

    3254

  • Year Built

    1929

  • $/SqFt

    $212

Awesome location has you a short walk to Butler, 56th and Illinois, and all things Mid-Town. MLS#21969864. Compass Indiana, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $345,000

Reduced By $15,000
View Details 28 Photos
On Market For 168 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    3

  • Sq. Ft.

    2184

  • Year Built

    1934

  • $/SqFt

    $158

House was remodeled in 2008. Move in ready! MLS#21970330. Todd Realty Group, LLC.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $275,000

Reduced By $100,000
View Details 30 Photos
On Market For 171 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    1976

  • Year Built

    1925

  • $/SqFt

    $139

1C Det garage sold 'AS IS'. Fenced yard. MLS#21969101. CENTURY 21 Scheetz.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $1,875,000

View Details 49 Photos
*POTENTIAL GREAT VALUE
On Market For 177 Days

  • Bedrooms

    4

  • Full Bath(s)

    5

  • Sq. Ft.

    5838

  • Year Built

    1937

  • $/SqFt

    $321

Seller financing is available. 5% INTEREST RATE! MLS#21968242. F.C. Tucker Company.

Butler Tarkington For Sale $529,000

Reduced By $70,000
View Details 27 Photos
On Market For 167 Days

  • Bedrooms

    3

  • Full Bath(s)

    2

  • Sq. Ft.

    2676

  • Year Built

    1936

  • $/SqFt

    $198

What pleasure to sit on the front patio or enjoy the privacy of the back deck. Garage sold "as is." MLS#21965827. F.C. Tucker Company.

Viewing HOMES 1 to 50 of 54

Highgarden

Call to Schedule a Showing

(317) 565-7160

(317) 565-7160